After weeks without a contract, Flagler County finally approves $350,000 animal control deal with Humane Society

Flagler County commissioners voted 5-0 on Monday to approve a one-year, $350,000 animal control contract with the Flagler Humane Society — ending a nearly four-week lapse in the county’s agreement with the nonprofit.

The agreement covers what county staff call “mandatory services”: dangerous-dog investigations, neglect investigations, rabies quarantines, sheltering and care for animals whose owners are detained, according to Commissioner Leann Pennington, who listed them at the meeting. Interim County Administrator Adam Mengel said the Humane Society will also help during declared local emergencies.

The contract also lets the Humane Society recover its costs for animals seized in cruelty or neglect cases, which Mengel said can stay at the shelter for months until a court decides what happens to them. Defendants are often ordered to reimburse the shelter, but most ignore those orders, he said. Such seizures have always been rare, he added, but costly when they arise.

For those services, the county will pay the Humane Society about $29,000 a month, Mengel said, noting that the total was slightly more than the county budgeted, but the amount was in line with what it has historically paid the nonprofit.

Commissioner Andy Dance said he favored the predictable annual cost, while other commissioners pointed to a provision in the agreement allowing the county to end the deal with 90 days’ notice.

Mengel acknowledged that neither side got everything it wanted in the weeks of negotiations leading up to the vote.

“Like any agreement, we’re not totally happy, they’re not totally happy,” he said.

Much of Monday’s discussion focused on a public records clause, that as presented to the board, said the Humane Society “shall be under no obligation to provide the county access to nonpublic records in its possession,” according to Pennington, who read it aloud.

Incoming Commissioner Theresa Pontieri urged the board to strike the clause, arguing that the nonprofit shouldn’t get to decide which of its records are nonpublic, and called for an audit. She said she addressed the board during public comment because Florida’s open-meetings laws barred her, as a commissioner-elect, from discussing the issue with members privately.

Pontieri, who won the commissions District 2 seat on Nov. 3 and is set to be sworn in Tuesday, previously served as Palm Coast’s vice mayor and the city’s liaison to the Humane Society. In that role, she said she had requested the nonprofit’s budgets but was told it did not want to provide them in a way that would make them public records, HomeFetch has reported.

County Attorney Michael Rodriguez responded that the clause was meant to cover the Humane Society’s own records unrelated to county business, such as its financial and personnel files, which he said fall outside of the definition of a public record under Chapter 119, Florida’s public records law, he said. Rather than strike the clause, commissioners adopted Rodriguez’s suggestion to replace “nonpublic” with wording that ties the exclusion directly to that law instead.

The Humane Society is fine with the change, Executive Director Amy Carotenuto said in an email Tuesday.

Under the contract, the county can still review records connected to the services it pays for, including the animals handled, where they were picked up and the costs involved, Rodriguez said, but it isn’t entitled to a blanket audit of the nonprofit’s finances. Commissioners did not add the audit requirement Pontieri sought, either. Carotenuto said full financial audits are expensive and that the Humane Society has an accountant perform a review of its finances every year.

Mengel said staff had separately expanded another provision so the Humane Society must provide records related to its work under the agreement to the public, not just the county.

Pontieri also asked the board to shorten the contract to six months, arguing that a tighter deadline would keep the county focused on finding a better long-term arrangement.

“I think that this keeps us hyperfocused on figuring out the best option for animal control in our county, and to be quite frank with you, I don’t think the Flagler Humane Society is that,” she said.

Carotenuto said she doesn’t believe Pontieri understands what animal control and sheltering involve, describing a recent hour in which staff cared for two litters of newborn kittens, arranged surgery for an injured stray cat and helped a woman with no money who needed to surrender seven dogs and a cat. She said that was an average day.

“I would love for anyone on the city council or county commission to truly spend a day with us,” she said.

Commissioner Kim Carney said no other agency is willing to take on the work. Sheriff Rick Staly told the board at a Nov. 9 workshop that his office isn’t the solution, citing cost, HomeFetch has reported.

“Nobody wants animal control,” Carney said Monday. “Sheriff doesn’t want it. We don’t want it. Palm Coast doesn’t want it.”

Pennington said the county couldn’t get Palm Coast to hold a joint meeting before the city’s council changed over, and that Amendment 3, the property tax measure voters approved Nov. 3, has further complicated the county’s options. In the end, commissioners kept the one-year term.

Mengel said staff will schedule joint meetings with Palm Coast and Flagler Beach, followed by a legislative priorities workshop in December and a meeting with the county’s legislative delegation in January.

Carotenuto said the Humane Society is glad negotiations are over and can now “focus on the animals and the job to be done.”

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top