Flagler sheriff pushes back on taking over animal control amid humane society contract standoff

As Flagler County looks for someone to handle animal control amid a nearly three-week contract stalemate with the Flagler Humane Society, commissioners weighed handing the job to the sheriff’s office Monday — but Sheriff Rick Staly said he doesn’t think his agency should take on the responsibility.

The county’s one-year contract with the nonprofit ran through Sept. 30 and was extended to allow more time for negotiations before lapsing Oct. 20, according to the county. The two sides remain divided over what the county should pay for the Humane Society’s services, HomeFetch has reported.

“We’ll work with you, but I don’t think we are the solution, primarily because I don’t see a funding source to do that,” Staly said.

Staly’s reluctance leaves commissioners with other options, including a new agreement with the Flagler Humane Society or running animal control themselves, an approach county staff said Nov. 2 that it prefers, HomeFetch has reported. Commissioner Kim Carney said Amendment 3, the property tax measure voters approved Nov. 3, will weigh heavily on that decision.

Some sheriff’s offices in Florida run animal control successfully, Staly said — but at a significant cost. He pointed to Citrus County, which he said budgets $5 million a year for animal control, and Brevard County, which he put at $5.1 million.

“What I’m not willing to do is take a problem that can’t be fixed because it’s not properly funded,” he said. “And that goes into Amendment 3.”

State law requires the sheriff’s office to handle only loose cattle, dangerous dogs and animal neglect and abuse cases, Staly told commissioners, and his agency’s first responsibility is to people.

Carney pushed back, asking Staly whether he saw the animals as innocent and arguing that the government has a duty to intervene when owners can’t care for them.

“Government has to step in and say you can’t have animals anymore because you can’t take care of them,” she said. “That’s our job as government.”

Staly said he didn’t disagree, but told commissioners that any new rules they adopt would need to come with the means to enforce them. He isn’t looking for a “Taj Mahal solution,” he said, but he isn’t willing to take on a program he can’t sustain.

Flagler County Sheriff Rick Staly speaks at a lectern during a Flagler County Commission workshop on animal control.
Flagler County Sheriff Rick Staly speaks to county commissioners during a workshop on animal control on Monday, Nov. 9, 2026. (Screenshot/Flagler County)

The lapsed contract is already affecting his deputies, according to the sheriff. They call animal control for dangerous dog cases and similar situations, he said, but his office was recently notified that the Humane Society’s after-hours service is no longer available because the county is out of contract.

In a Nov. 4 Facebook post, the Humane Society said its had paused officer pickups for routine calls in unincorporated areas but is still responding to sheriff’s office requests, cruelty and neglect cases, and dangerous dogs. The post directs residents to call the sheriff’s office after hours.

Asked what after-hours coverage is in place, the sheriff’s office spokesman Jake Arthur said in an email that the agency “cannot speak to FHS services,” and did not address questions about the notice Staly said his office received ending after-hours service.

Humane Society Executive Director Amy Carotenuto said in an interview Tuesday that the organization is still responding to after-hours emergency calls. She said the Humane Society first emailed the sheriff’s office dispatch about the change in service, then sent a second email clarifying that the Humane Society is “still on for 24/7 emergencies.”

Commission Chair Leann Pennington asked whether the sheriff’s office would consider a narrower model, handling only those core cases from a small facility built with state and local money already set aside for a shelter.



Staly said he is willing to work with both the county and Palm Coast but questioned what such a facility would require, including training, vehicles and staff to monitor the animals in its care.

The sheriff also praised his agency’s partnership with the Humane Society, which has brought puppies and kittens into the county jail for inmates to care for before the animals are adopted.

“Our animals in Flagler County are important to us, but it’s expensive to do it right,” he said.

Commissioners also reviewed a contract proposal from the Humane Society on Monday but took no action. They’re scheduled to take up animal control again Nov. 16, and Carney urged staff to bring something forward by then, saying the county needs “to get something in writing.”


Update: This story was updated Nov. 10 to include a statement from the Flagler County Sheriff’s Office and the Flagler Humane Society.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top