Flagler County and its Humane Society still can’t agree on an animal control contract

Flagler Humane Society Executive Director Amy Carotenuto speaks at the lectern before Flagler County commissioners during a meeting on the county’s animal control contract.

Flagler County remains without an animal control contract after commissioners and the Flagler Humane Society failed to reach a temporary deal Monday — leaving it unclear whether the shelter will keep taking in stray animals from unincorporated parts of the county.

The two sides have been without an agreement since Oct. 20, when the county’s previous contract with the Humane Society expired after it was extended to allow time for negotiations, Interim County Administrator Adam Mengel said at Monday’s meeting.

Flagler County has no animal control officers of its own and instead relies on the nonprofit for those services and sheltering, HomeFetch has reported. But that relationship has grown increasingly strained in recent years as commissioners have pressed the organization for more financial accountability.

Mengel presented the contract the county has offered for the 2026-27 fiscal year, which would narrow the services it pays the Humane Society to provide, acknowledging the organization and its board do not support the proposed cuts.

“I would just hope that maybe we would have more conversations before we sign a contract where we lessen our services,” Humane Society Executive Director Amy Carotenuto said.

Flagler Humane Society Executive Director Amy Carotenuto speaks during a Flagler County Commission meeting on Monday, Nov. 2, 2026. (Screenshot/Flagler County)

Commissioner Kim Carney moved to extend the expired contract through Dec. 31 with a 3% increase and called for a new contract to be negotiated by the commission’s second meeting in December.

Because an extension would need the Humane Society’s agreement, Commissioner Andy Dance asked Carotenuto to confirm the shelter would accept the terms before commissioners voted. She said she could not commit to the deal without her board.

“I can’t speak for my board of directors,” she said.

Carotenuto told commissioners she believed the Humane Society had already agreed to an earlier temporary extension but was unsure about changes to its services.

Carney amended her motion to cover only a $20,963 budget transfer for the county’s outstanding obligations from the 2025-26 fiscal year. It passed 4-0.

The vote settled the county’s bills from last fiscal year, Mengel said. But it didn’t put an agreement in place going forward.



In the meantime, Carotenuto, discussing the county’s proposal to limit the calls its officers handle, told commissioners: “We’ve had to turn people away over the last few days and the sheriff’s department has still called us out and we’re not going to tell them no.”

Commission Chair Leann Pennington pressed several times on whether a resident who walked into the shelter with a stray would be turned away. Carotenuto said that depends on whether the county will help cover the cost, adding that the Humane Society’s board is “very adamant that there’s only so much upside down we can be.”

Dance raised a related concern. One of Carotenuto’s emails to county officials, he said, stated that a caller had been told the Humane Society could no longer respond to calls for stray animals. When he asked why the organization would stop a service that’s part of its mission, Carotenuto said responding to strays had been a contracted county service for 40 years.

“You’re right, it is our mission, but you know, there’s things we want to do and then if we don’t have the funding to do it, how are we supposed to do it?” she said.

Pennington cited the Humane Society’s 2024 IRS filing, saying it reported $3.6 million in revenue and stated that an animal in need is never turned away. Earlier in the meeting, Carotenuto had said the shelter has never turned away an animal in need from local governments it contracts with.

The filing, which covers the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30, 2025, reports $3,611,939 in revenue, up from about $2.7 million the year before. The line Pennington cited appears in the filing’s description of the shelter’s veterinary and medical services.

Under the county’s proposed contract, the Humane Society’s services would be limited to three types of cases, according to Mengel: dangerous dogs, neglect and animals left behind when their owners are taken into custody by the sheriff’s office.

Mengel said the county’s main goal is more certainty in its spending.

Flagler pays about $18,000 a month for animal control, Mengel said. Sheltering is less predictable: The county is billed $156 for each stray’s five day hold, so the total varies with the number of animals brought in.

The Humane Society has told officials that caring for a large dog costs closer to $500, and its proposed rate of about $300 per animal would effectively double the current fee, Mengel said.

Carotenuto said that under the proposal, the organization would have to pay for its own officers “other than the few hours here and there that are dangerous dog cases, or cruelty cases.”

Carney said she would support paying for animal control by the hour, but only if the work is documented so taxpayers can see what they’re paying for.

“This is public money — we’ve asked the humane society to be accountable for public money,” Carney said. “This is not something new. This has been going on for two years.”

The organization sends the county detailed notes on every case each month, Carotenuto said.

Palm Coast officials have raised similar concerns. At an Aug. 26 joint meeting of the Palm Coast City Council and Flagler County Commission, Vice Mayor Theresa Pontieri said the Humane Society declined to give the city copies of its budgets or a report on its operations prepared by a University of Florida consultant, HomeFetch reported.

Officials are weighing other options. Mengel said county staff now prefer the approach Palm Coast takes: The city runs its own animal control and pays the Humane Society to care for the animals its officers pick up. A second shelter, mainly for lost and stray pets, is also in the works, HomeFetch reported in August.



Commissioners will take up animal control again at a Nov. 9 workshop, where the Humane Society can present its own proposal and the sheriff’s office plans to give a presentation, according to Mengel. Until then, the county expects the Humane Society to keep handling dangerous dog cases, he said.

Carotenuto told commissioners she wants to keep working toward an agreement.

“I would love an opportunity to work something moving forward,” she said.


Update: This story has been updated to include the Flagler Humane Society’s tax filing for the fiscal year that ended Sept. 30, 2025, which reports about $3.6 million in revenue, the figure Pennington cited.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

2 thoughts on “Flagler County and its Humane Society still can’t agree on an animal control contract”

  1. more and more animals, are abused,neglected,left behind. more and more people are moving into Flagler with animals,food is so high,feenbd the kids,dump the dog. If they surrender the animal,there comes a fee,so dump. Flagler Humane society does not dicreminate they take in all. AND AT A COST. County you need to step up and help them. Yes to a second shelter. More help with dangerous dogs. You just cant always kill them.
    please,stop all thisover devolpment,you rather have more buildings and less animals,that is a fact

  2. Can’t they get volunteers until they straighten this out? There’s a lot of great people here who I’m sure would be happy to volunyeer so no aniimals are overlooked and they straighten this out reasonably. I wish I could I love animals and used to help out many years ago with the cats when we took care of the feral colonies to spay neuter and make sure they had shelter and food. Just an idea not sure of the entire situation but years ago the humane society used to collect a few when people would decide they no longer wanted their responsibility they signed u for when adoro g or purchasing a per. Which is more than fair because when yu decide to be responsible for any helpless animal of any kind. It’s should be taken very seriously because your not just saving a life especially through afoption. Your agreeing to take full responsibility as a owner to ensure that animal is well taken care of for its life span. I’ve seen people not just in town here but all over the country make a snap decision to adopt a furbaby, then decide it’s to much responsibility or move & leave the animal loose or just dump them like trash. My mom & I had several encounter long ago where a ct or dog would jump on thecr at town center when we’d go for a nightly walk around the lake. I’ve seen past neighbors cats behind the old Bealls Outlet on old kings rd. Or by Dunkin Donuts werw the Cat Colonies used to be. I’m sure they can respectfully come up with agrreement were it’s fair to all involved & start saving. these helpless animals lives. The price of utilities and taxes I’m sure could afford to give a small slice to the animal shelter. Its very upsetting that with all the dislaced animals & wildlife now out of control being forced off their once safe land by expansion that Palm Coast should have (even a small) wildlife rehab or sanctuary. Give back to nature what we take away even a simple gesture & educational building to teach residents about the abundant wildlife this town once had as it thrived. As well as safety for the children & the wildlife to co-exist. It’s heartbreaking when an animal is hurt or hit by a vehicle & you witness their demise by shooting them. When alot of them can be saved & kept at a educational sanctuary after rehab or reintroduced to the wild. It could also be a good class trip for elementary students & residents. Can’t they get volunteers until they straighten this out? There’s a lot of great people here who I’m sure would be happy to volunyeer so no aniimals are overlooked and they straighten this out reasonably. I wish I could I love animals and used to help out many years ago with the cats when we took care of the feral colonies to spay neuter and make sure they had shelter and food. Just an idea not sure of the entire situation but years ago the humane society used to collect a few when people would decide they no longer wanted their responsibility they signed u for when adoro g or purchasing a per. Which is more than fair because when yu decide to be responsible for any helpless animal of any kind. It’s should be taken very seriously because your not just saving a life especially through afoption. Your agreeing to take full responsibility as a owner to ensure that animal is well taken care of for its life span. I’ve seen people not just in town here but all over the country make a snap decision to adopt a furbaby, then decide it’s to much responsibility or move & leave the animal loose or just dump them like trash. My mom & I had several encounter long ago where a ct or dog would jump on thecr at town center when we’d go for a nightly walk around the lake. I’ve seen past neighbors cats behind the old Bealls Outlet on old kings rd. Or by Dunkin Donuts werw the Cat Colonies used to be. I’m sure they can respectfully come up with agrreement were it’s fair to all involved & start saving. these helpless animals lives. The price of utilities and taxes I’m sure could afford to give a small slice to the animal shelter. Its very upsetting that with all the dislaced animals & wildlife now out of control being forced off their once safe land by expansion that Palm Coast should have (even a small) wildlife rehab or sanctuary. Give back to nature what we take away even a simple gesture & educational building to teach residents about the abundant wildlife this town once had as it thrived. As well as safety for the children & the wildlife to co-exist. It’s heartbreaking when an animal is hurt or hit by a vehicle & you witness their demise by shooting them. When alot of them can be saved & kept at a educational sanctuary after rehab or reintroduced to the wild. It could also be a good class trip for elementary students & residents. Can’t they get volunteers until they straighten this out? There’s a lot of great people here who I’m sure would be happy to volunyeer so no aniimals are overlooked and they straighten this out reasonably. I wish I could I love animals and used to help out many years ago with the cats when we took care of the feral colonies to spay neuter and make sure they had shelter and food. Just an idea not sure of the entire situation but years ago the humane society used to collect a few when people would decide they no longer wanted their responsibility they signed u for when adoro g or purchasing a per. Which is more than fair because when yu decide to be responsible for any helpless animal of any kind. It’s should be taken very seriously because your not just saving a life especially through afoption. Your agreeing to take full responsibility as a owner to ensure that animal is well taken care of for its life span. I’ve seen people not just in town here but all over the country make a snap decision to adopt a furbaby, then decide it’s to much responsibility or move & leave the animal loose or just dump them like trash. My mom & I had several encounter long ago where a ct or dog would jump on thecr at town center when we’d go for a nightly walk around the lake. I’ve seen past neighbors cats behind the old Bealls Outlet on old kings rd. Or by Dunkin Donuts werw the Cat Colonies used to be. I’m sure they can respectfully come up with agrreement were it’s fair to all involved & start saving. these helpless animals lives. The price of utilities and taxes I’m sure could afford to give a small slice to the animal shelter. Its very upsetting that with all the dislaced animals & wildlife now out of control being forced off their once safe land by expansion that Palm Coast should have (even a small) wildlife rehab or sanctuary. Give back to nature what we take away even a simple gesture & educational building to teach residents about the abundant wildlife this town once had as it thrived. As well as safety for the children & the wildlife to co-exist. It’s heartbreaking when an animal is hurt or hit by a vehicle & you witness their demise by shooting them. When alot of them can be saved & kept at a educational sanctuary after rehab or reintroduced to the wild. It could also be a good class trip for elementary students & residents.

Scroll to Top